As a devoted pet parent, witnessing your beloved dog engage in pica â the consumption of non-food items like dirt, rocks, or fabric â can be incredibly concerning. It’s a complex behavior, often signaling underlying nutritional deficiencies, digestive upset, boredom, or even anxiety. Finding the right dietary support is a critical step in helping your furry friend overcome this challenging habit and thrive.
Iâm Mo Mahin â the founder and writer behind Furric. With over 15 years as an animal behaviorist and pet nutritionist, I meticulously analyze veterinary safety standards, deep market research, and thousands of real pet owner testimonials to bring you the most trusted advice.
My passion lies in empowering you with the knowledge to make informed choices for your dog’s health and happiness, especially when facing unique dietary needs. Understanding the complex reasons behind your dog’s unusual eating habits is crucial, and our guide to the best dog food for pica offers expert insights and top product recommendations to nourish them back to optimal health.
How To Choose The Best Dog Food For Pica
Selecting the right food for a dog with pica goes beyond just taste; itâs about addressing potential underlying causes and providing complete, balanced nutrition. Hereâs what to prioritize:
Nutritional Completeness & Digestibility
A primary cause of pica can be nutritional deficiencies. Look for foods that are AAFCO compliant and provide a complete and balanced diet for your dog’s life stage. Highly digestible ingredients ensure your dog is actually absorbing the nutrients they need, reducing the urge to seek them out from non-food sources. Ingredients like easily digestible proteins, healthy fats, and appropriate fiber sources are key.
Ingredient Quality & Transparency
Prioritize foods with high-quality, human-grade ingredients and clear labeling. Avoid fillers, artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives that can upset sensitive stomachs or offer little nutritional value. Limited ingredient diets can also be beneficial if allergies or sensitivities are suspected contributors to pica, as they simplify the diet and reduce potential irritants.
Texture & Palatability
For dogs with pica, sometimes the issue isn’t just nutrition, but also boredom or an oral fixation. Offering a food with an engaging texture or a highly palatable flavor can help satisfy these urges through appropriate means. Wet foods, air-dried kibbles, or even toppers can add excitement and interest to mealtime, redirecting their focus from inappropriate chewing or eating behaviors.
Quick Comparison
On smaller screens, swipe sideways to see the full table.
| Model | Type | Best For | Key Feature | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACANA Butcherâs Favorites | Dry Kibble | Overall Wellness | High Protein, Grain-Free | Amazon |
| Portland Pet Food Company Pouches | Wet Topper | Picky Eaters | Human-Grade, Limited Ingredient | Amazon |
| Dog Greens Multivitamin (2 Pack) | Powder Supplement | Long-Term Value | Organic Superfoods, Bioavailable Nutrients | Amazon |
| Weruva Pumpkin Variety Pack | Wet Food | Gentle Digestion | Fiber-Rich Pumpkin, Grain-Free | Amazon |
| Dog Greens Multivitamin (12 oz) | Powder Supplement | Nutrient Booster | Organic Kelp, Spirulina, Sea Moss | Amazon |
| Dog Greens Plant-Based (4 Pack) | Powder Supplement | Ultimate Greens Bulk | 100% Human Grade, Vegan | Amazon |
| Green Foods Barley Dog Formula | Powder Supplement | Grass Eating Support | Barley Grass, Digestion Aid | Amazon |
| Earth Animal No Hide Stix | Chew Treat | Chew Redirection | Rawhide-Free, Easily Digestible | Amazon |
| Pawstruck Air Dried Dog Food | Air-Dried Kibble | Allergy-Friendly Kibble | 96% Real Beef, Grain-Free | Amazon |
InâDepth Reviews: Best Dog Food For Pica
1. ACANA Butcherâs Favorites Grain-Free Dry Dog Food
The ACANA Butcherâs Favorites Grain-Free Dry Dog Food is a standout choice for dogs struggling with pica, offering a high-protein, nutrient-dense formulation that addresses many underlying dietary needs. With 70% animal ingredients, including fresh or raw free-run chicken, chicken liver, and turkey, it provides the essential amino acids and energy active dogs need, while also supporting digestive health, a healthy weight, and a shiny coat.
Dog owners consistently praise its palatability, with many noting even the pickiest eaters devour every meal. Several caregivers observed improved stool consistency and overall vitality after switching to ACANA, suggesting its easily digestible formula and quality ingredients contribute significantly to better gut health. The inclusion of real chicken jerky pieces also adds an enticing texture that keeps dogs engaged at mealtime.
This premium dry kibble is an excellent foundational food for any dog, especially those whose pica might stem from inadequate nutrition or digestive upset. Its commitment to quality ingredients and comprehensive benefits makes it a smart investment for your dog’s long-term health and a strong deterrent against non-food cravings.
Why we love it
- Rich in high-quality animal protein (70%).
- Supports digestive health and healthy weight.
- Includes enticing real chicken jerky pieces.
- Grain-free, suitable for sensitive dogs.
Good to know
- Premium price point.
- Contains poultry and egg, not suitable for specific allergies.
2. Portland Pet Food Company Fresh Dog Food Pouches
The Portland Pet Food Company Fresh Dog Food Pouches offer a fantastic solution for dogs with pica, particularly those who are finicky eaters or require highly digestible, limited-ingredient options. These human-grade wet meals and toppers are shelf-stable and made with 11 or fewer identifiable ingredients, providing transparency and quality that can make a real difference for sensitive pups.
Pet parents with picky eaters or dogs with sensitive stomachs report remarkable success, noting that their dogs eagerly finish their meals when these pouches are added. Many have highlighted significant improvements in digestion and a reduction in stomach upset, attributing it to the fresh, wholesome ingredients. The variety pack ensures your dog stays interested, with flavors like salmon, beef, chicken, turkey, and pork.
Whether used as a full meal, a mixer with kibble, or a enticing topper, these pouches provide a nutrient-dense boost that can help address nutritional gaps contributing to pica. Their soft texture is also ideal for senior dogs or those recovering from dental procedures, ensuring comfortable and appealing meal times.
Why we love it
- Human-grade, limited ingredients.
- Shelf-stable, no refrigeration needed until opened.
- Highly palatable for picky eaters.
- Supports digestive health.
Good to know
- Can be pricey for full meals.
- Some variation in texture reported in older batches.
3. Organic Dog Multivitamin Supplement (Dog Greens 2 Pack)
For pet parents seeking to address potential nutritional deficiencies that might lead to pica, the Organic Dog Multivitamin Supplement by Dog Greens (2 Pack) offers an exceptional, comprehensive solution. This human-grade powder is packed with organic superfoods like barley grass, wheat grass, kelp, spirulina, and chlorella, providing a bioavailable source of essential vitamins, minerals, fiber, and antioxidants.
Dedicated pet caregivers have observed remarkable transformations, with some noting increased energy, softer coats, and significant improvements in their dogs’ overall health, even resolving issues like lethargy and joint discomfort. The supplement is often praised for its ability to balance homemade diets, making it easier to ensure your dog receives all necessary nutrients, and many report that their dogs readily accept the earthy flavor mixed into their food.
This larger 2-pack offers fantastic value for consistent, long-term use, ensuring your dog gets the vital nutrients they need to thrive. Itâs an excellent choice for dogs with pica, as a well-nourished system is less likely to crave non-food items, supporting their immune, digestive, and overall wellness.
Why we love it
- Comprehensive organic superfood blend.
- Addresses nutritional deficiencies, a pica cause.
- Human-grade, no fillers or synthetics.
- Excellent value in a 2-pack.
Good to know
- Powder form requires mixing into food.
- Some dogs may be allergic to specific ingredients like wheat grass.
4. Weruva Classic Dog Food, Pumpkin to Talk About Variety Pack
The Weruva Classic Dog Food, “Let’s Give Em’ Pumpkin to Talk About” Variety Pack, is an excellent option for dogs with pica, particularly if digestive upset or a lack of fiber is a contributing factor. These wet foods are crafted in human food facilities with visible, high-quality ingredients and feature fiber-rich pumpkin to support gut motility and overall digestive health.
Senior pet caregivers and those with dogs prone to sensitive stomachs rave about this food, noting how eagerly their dogs consume it and the significant improvement in stool quality. Many have found it to be a gentle yet effective solution for occasional constipation or tummy aches, helping to regulate their dog’s digestive system. The grain-free, gluten-free, and non-GMO formulation further reduces potential irritants.
Offering a delicious and easily digestible meal, this variety pack helps ensure your dog feels satisfied and well-nourished, potentially reducing the urge to consume non-food items due to discomfort or nutritional imbalance. Itâs a fantastic choice for supporting a healthy gut, which is foundational to addressing pica.
Why we love it
- Fiber-rich pumpkin for digestive health.
- Made in human food facilities with quality ingredients.
- Grain-free, gluten-free, and non-GMO.
- Highly palatable for picky eaters.
Good to know
- Smaller cans may not be sufficient for large breeds.
- Primarily for adult dogs.
5. Superfood Multivitamin Powder (Dog Greens 12oz)
The Dog Greens Superfood Multivitamin Powder in the 12oz size is an excellent daily supplement to ensure your dog receives a full spectrum of nutrients, which can be crucial for addressing pica rooted in dietary deficiencies. This human-grade blend features organic kelp, spirulina, sea moss, wheat and barley grass, chlorella, and alfalfa, delivering bioavailable vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.
Pet parents report significant improvements in their dogs’ energy levels, coat health, and digestion. One particularly impactful story highlighted how this powder, when combined with homemade food, helped resolve a dog’s long-standing weight issues, lethargy, and even a limp. Many attest to its palatability, with dogs eagerly licking their bowls clean, making it easy to incorporate into kibble, raw, or homemade meals.
For dogs exhibiting pica, supplementing their diet with a comprehensive multivitamin like Dog Greens can help fill nutritional gaps, potentially reducing the innate drive to consume non-food items. Its long-standing reputation and positive feedback from thousands of users make it a trusted choice for promoting vibrant health and preventing future issues.
Why we love it
- Rich in organic and wild-harvested superfoods.
- Supports energy, immune, joint, and skin health.
- Human-grade ingredients, no fillers.
- Trusted brand for over two decades.
Good to know
- Powder form requires mixing.
- Expiration date should be checked upon arrival for maximum use.
6. Organic Plant-Based Supplement for Dogs (Dog Greens 4 Pack)
The Organic Plant-Based Supplement for Dogs (Dog Greens 4 Pack) offers a substantial, long-term supply of vital nutrients, making it an excellent investment for pet parents committed to addressing pica through comprehensive dietary support. This 100% human-grade, vegan powder is free from fillers and artificial ingredients, focusing on pure organic barley grass, wheat grass, alfalfa, kelp, Irish moss, spirulina, and chlorella.
Devoted dog owners often share stories of dramatic health turnarounds, including resolution of weight issues, increased vitality, and improved coat quality, especially when used to balance homemade diets. The consistent feedback highlights its effectiveness in providing essential vitamins and minerals that might be missing from standard diets, thereby reducing the dog’s drive to seek out non-food items.
This 4-pack bundle is ideal for multi-pet households or for ensuring a continuous supply for a dog with persistent pica concerns. By providing a rich source of bioavailable nutrients, it supports overall immune, digestive, and skin health, fostering a well-balanced internal system less prone to the behaviors associated with pica.
Why we love it
- Large 4-pack for long-term use and value.
- 100% human-grade, vegan, and organic.
- Comprehensive blend of essential vitamins and minerals.
- Supports overall health, including skin, coat, and digestion.
Good to know
- Higher initial cost due to bulk purchase.
- Some picky dogs might initially hesitate with the taste.
7. Green Foods Corporation Barley Dog Canine Formula
The Green Foods Corporation Barley Dog Canine Formula is specifically beneficial for dogs with pica, particularly those who exhibit excessive grass eating or consume other outdoor non-food items. This powder supplement, made from barley grass, aims to provide essential nutrients that might be missing, helping to curb these specific behaviors while supporting overall digestion and energy levels.
Many dog parents have found success in reducing their dogs’ grass eating habits after incorporating this supplement into their diet. Owners of senior dogs especially note improved digestion and increased vitality. The bacon flavor often makes it highly palatable, with even picky eaters gobbling it up when mixed with their regular food, and some report it helps freshen bad breath.
If your dog’s pica manifests as consuming grass, dirt, or even feces, this barley grass formula can be a targeted and effective dietary intervention. By providing a clean, pesticide-free source of greens, it helps satisfy an underlying nutritional need and promotes a healthier gut, redirecting their cravings away from potentially harmful outdoor elements.
Why we love it
- Specifically targets grass-eating pica.
- Promotes healthy skin, coat, and digestion.
- May increase energy levels, especially in seniors.
- No pesticides or unhealthy chemicals.
Good to know
- Some dogs may be allergic to barley.
- Not all picky eaters will accept the bacon flavor.
8. Earth Animal No Hide Stix
While not a primary food, the Earth Animal No Hide Stix are an invaluable tool for managing pica, especially when the behavior stems from boredom, anxiety, or an oral fixation. These all-natural, easily digestible chews offer a healthy alternative to rawhide and can effectively redirect your dog’s urge to chew on inappropriate items.
Pet parents of small and extra-small dogs, including picky Morkie puppies and Havanese, consistently report that their dogs adore these stix and stay happily occupied for extended periods. Many highlight the peace of mind knowing these are rawhide-free, made with simple, humanely raised ingredients, and digest well without causing stomach upset. Theyâre also praised for being mess-free and odor-free.
For dogs with pica, offering a safe, long-lasting, and satisfying chew like the No Hide Stix can be a crucial behavioral intervention. It provides an appropriate outlet for their chewing instincts, enriching their environment and helping to break the cycle of consuming non-food objects. Remember to always supervise your dog while they chew.
Why we love it
- Healthy, rawhide-free alternative.
- Long-lasting and easily digestible.
- Great for dental health.
- No bleach, synthetics, or foul odor.
Good to know
- Requires supervision during chewing.
- Sticks are small, best for dogs under 10 lbs.
9. Pawstruck Air Dried Dog Food with Real Beef
The Pawstruck Air Dried Dog Food with Real Beef is a premium, nutrient-dense option that can be highly beneficial for dogs with pica, especially those with sensitivities to common allergens like chicken or grains. Its air-dried preparation method retains maximum nutrition, offering a palatable and easily digestible alternative to highly processed kibble, with real beef as the #1 ingredient.
Dog parents with allergy-prone pups rave about this food, noting significant improvements in coat health, reduced itching, and healthy stool consistency. Many appreciate the single-protein, grain-free, and gluten-free formula, finding it gentle on sensitive stomachs. The unique crunchy texture is also a hit, making mealtime engaging for even the pickiest eaters.
For dogs whose pica might be linked to underlying allergies or a diet lacking in bioavailable nutrients, Pawstruck provides a wholesome, high-protein foundation. Its commitment to quality ingredients and gentle processing ensures your dog receives optimal nourishment, potentially reducing the drive to seek out non-food items for missing elements. The trial bag is a great way to introduce it to your pup.
Why we love it
- Air-dried to preserve maximum nutrients.
- 96% real beef, single-protein formula.
- Grain-free, gluten-free, and non-GMO.
- Vet recommended and AAFCO compliant.
Good to know
- Trial bag is small; larger bags desired by users.
- Texture is very crunchy, potentially hard for some small dogs.
Safety & Care Tips
Consult Your Veterinarian
Before making any significant dietary changes or introducing new supplements, always consult your veterinarian. Pica can be a symptom of underlying medical conditions (like parasites, anemia, or gastrointestinal issues) that require professional diagnosis and treatment. Your vet can help rule out these causes and guide you toward the most appropriate nutritional and behavioral strategies.
Observe & Manage Environment
While addressing dietary needs is crucial, it’s equally important to manage your dog’s environment. Remove access to non-food items they tend to eat. Provide plenty of appropriate chew toys and mental stimulation to combat boredom and anxiety, which can also contribute to pica. Consistent supervision, especially during outdoor time, is key to preventing the ingestion of harmful objects.
FAQ
What exactly is pica in dogs?
Can diet really help with pica?
What ingredients should I look for in dog food for pica?
How long does it take to see results from a diet change?
Final Thoughts: The Verdict
For most pet parents, the best dog food for pica winner is the ACANA Butcherâs Favorites Grain-Free Dry Dog Food because its high-protein, nutrient-dense formula addresses core dietary needs and is highly palatable. If you want a versatile, human-grade option for picky eaters or sensitive stomachs, grab the Portland Pet Food Company Fresh Dog Food Pouches. And for comprehensive nutritional support and excellent long-term value, nothing beats the Organic Dog Multivitamin Supplement (Dog Greens 2 Pack).